The fee gap: what 20 years of fund data say stock-picking costs

Morningstar's 2026 fee study: broad index funds cost 0.09% a year, against 0.57% for active funds. SPIVA year-end 2025: 92.9% of large-cap active funds trailed the S&P 500 over 20 years — a $26,001 gap on $10,000.

AI illustration for this news story: The fee gap: what 20 years of fund data say stock-picking costs
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

The race starts with a handicap

Every fund charges a fee, taken as a percentage of the money invested, every year — whether the fund does well or not. That fee is the one part of a fund's result that is known in advance, and it is the gap between two ways of owning the stock market. Morningstar's 2026 US Fund Fee Study, published on May 19, 2026, puts the numbers on it: in 2025, the average expense ratio paid by fund investors fell to 0.32%, from 0.80% in 2006, and investors saved an estimated $6.8 billion in fund expenses last year.

The averages hide a wide split. Broad index funds cost 0.09% a year on an asset-weighted basis in 2025, against 0.57% for actively managed funds. Strategic-beta funds, which track rules-based indexes, sat between them at 0.16%. Many prominent index funds already charge less than 0.05%. At the other end, the average fee for new mutual funds topped 1.00% in 2025, the first time since 2015. The stock-picking side of the trade starts every year 0.48 percentage points behind the index side — before a single stock is picked.

What funds cost in 2025Source: Morningstar
  • Broad index funds0.09% a year
  • Strategic-beta funds0.16% a year
  • Active funds0.57% a year
  • New mutual funds, averageover 1.00% a year
  • All funds, average paid0.32% a year
Close-up of a magnifying glass over a printed fund fee statement on a wooden desk, warm light, dark moody background with empty space above
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

Twenty years of scorekeeping

S&P Dow Jones Indices has run its SPIVA scorecard for 25 years, comparing actively managed funds with their benchmarks and counting funds that closed or merged along the way, so failures are not quietly dropped. The year-end 2025 edition, with data as of December 31, 2025, is a hard year for the stock-picking side: 78.8% of actively managed large-cap funds trailed the S&P 500 in 2025, up from 65% in 2024 — the fourth-worst year for active large-cap managers in the scorecard's history.

The longer the period, the wider the gap. Over 10 years, 85.6% of large-cap funds trailed the index; over 15 years, 89.9%; over 20 years, 92.9%. Across all domestic funds, 95.0% trailed their benchmark over 20 years. And most funds do not even survive the race: of the 760 large-cap funds that existed at the start of 2006, only 34.6% — about 263 — were still operating at the end of 2025, and only about 54 of the 760, or 7.1%, finished ahead of the S&P 500 over the full 20 years.

What the gap is worth in dollars

SPIVA also reports average annualized returns, which turn the percentages into dollars. Over the 20 years to December 31, 2025, the S&P 500 returned 11.00% a year with dividends reinvested, turning $10,000 into $80,623. The average large-cap fund, weighted by assets, returned 9.62% a year, turning the same $10,000 into $62,776. The equal-weighted average fund returned 8.86% a year, or $54,622. The gap between the index and the average fund is $17,847 on an asset-weighted basis and $26,001 on an equal-weighted basis — about a third of the index outcome, from a difference of 2.14 percentage points a year.

Fees alone explain much of it, and the arithmetic is simple to check. Take a hypothetical $10,000 invested for 30 years at a gross return of 7% a year, with nothing added or withdrawn. At a 0.09% fee it grows to $74,225. At a 0.57% fee it grows to $64,852 — $9,373 less. At a 1.00% fee it grows to $57,435 — $16,790 less than the low-fee case. With no fee at all it would reach $76,123. The returns are identical in all three cases; only the fee changes. A fee looks small as a percentage and large as a balance, because it compounds every year for decades.

Why cost predicts outcomes

Morningstar's conclusion from the fee study is blunt: cost remains one of the most reliable predictors of fund success, because fees are certain, persistent, and directly reduce investor returns. Lower-cost funds tend to outperform and survive at higher rates than their more expensive peers. The fee is charged in good years and bad ones, and it is the only part of the return an investor can control before buying.

That does not settle the choice for anyone — a fund's strategy, its holdings and its risks still matter, and past results say nothing certain about the next year. But it does say where to start the comparison: the expense ratio, printed in every fund's prospectus, and the gap between what the average investor actually paid and what the average fund charged. In 2025, the low-cost side of that gap was 0.09% a year. The question is what the extra 0.48 percentage points on the other side is buying. Educational content, not investment advice.

Sources

Educational content, not investment advice. Facts as of the publish time above; figures come from the linked sources and markets change quickly. Genexus Alpha is not a registered investment adviser or broker.