Dollar-cost averaging in the fastest crash ever: what 2020 showed

In 2020 the S&P 500 fell 33.9% in 33 days, then finished the year up 16.26%. A $1,000-a-month buyer ended with $14,148, ahead of the $13,951 from investing $12,000 all at once.

AI illustration for this news story: Dollar-cost averaging in the fastest crash ever: what 2020 showed
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

Thirty-three days that broke the record books

On February 19, 2020, the S&P 500 closed at a record 3,386.15. Thirty-three days later, on March 23, it closed at 2,237.40 — a fall of 33.9% in 33 days, across 23 trading days. The index crossed the 20% bear-market line in 16 trading sessions. It was the fastest bear market ever recorded.

The recovery was just as fast. By August 18 the index closed at 3,389.78, above the February record, and it ended the year at 3,756.07 — up 16.26% from the 3,230.78 close at the end of 2019. A full bear market and a full recovery fit inside six months.

What the monthly buyer actually bought

Take a buyer who put $1,000 into an S&P 500 fund on the last trading day of each month in 2020, at that day's closing level. In January the $1,000 bought 0.3100 shares at 3,225.52. In March, at the month-end close of 2,584.59, the same $1,000 bought 0.3869 shares — 24.8% more shares for the same money.

March and April together bought 0.7303 shares; January and February bought 0.6485. Over the full year the $12,000 bought 3.76674 shares at an average cost of $3,185.78. At the December 31 close of 3,756.07, the position was worth $14,148 — a return of 17.90% on the money put in.

What the lump sum did

Now take a second buyer with the same $12,000, invested in full at the start of the year at the December 31, 2019 close of 3,230.78. That bought 3.71427 shares. At the December 31, 2020 close of 3,756.07, the position was worth $13,951 — a return of 16.26%.

The monthly buyer finished $197 ahead, with 1.41% more shares. The reason is the calendar: the crash landed in the middle of the monthly schedule, so the cheapest months bought the most shares, while the lump sum had no cash left for the March low. But this is the exception, not the rule. Morningstar's reading of Vanguard's 2012 study found that spreading purchases out came out ahead in only about one-third of rolling 10-year periods — in rising markets, money invested sooner usually wins. 2020 paid the monthly buyer because the drawdown was deep, fast, and early in the schedule.

The 2020 scoreboardSource: Yahoo Finance
  • S&P 500, February 19 peak3,386.15
  • S&P 500, March 23 trough2,237.40, down 33.9% in 33 days
  • Monthly buyer, $1,000 a month3.76674 shares, $14,148 at year-end
  • Lump sum, $12,000 at the start3.71427 shares, $13,951 at year-end
  • The gap$197 in the monthly buyer's favour
An empty trading hall at night under cold blue light, with a red glow on the floor
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

The lesson is the schedule, not the crash

Dollar-cost averaging is a schedule, not a forecast. The fixed monthly payment buys more shares when prices fall and fewer when they rise, without anyone needing to call the bottom. Investopedia describes the method as "meant to help investors manage risk instead of increasing profitability" — the point is steadiness, not a higher return.

The method has limits. It averages the price paid over time; it does not fix a bad asset, and it does not protect against a market that falls and stays down. It also works best with a broad index: Investopedia notes it is far less risky with index funds than with individual stocks, where one company can keep falling on its own.

What 2020 showed is when the schedule pays: a deep, fast fall early in the plan, followed by a recovery. The monthly buyer did not predict any of it. The buyer simply kept the schedule while prices fell, and the schedule did the rest. Educational content, not investment advice.

Sources

Educational content, not investment advice. Facts as of the publish time above; figures come from the linked sources and markets change quickly. Genexus Alpha is not a registered investment adviser or broker.