Anthropic's debut soars 17% but fails to revive the AI trade

Anthropic closed 17% above its $83 IPO price in a record $81 billion debut, but the S&P 500 still fell 2% as investors kept questioning whether AI spending will pay off.

AI illustration for this news story: Anthropic's debut soars 17% but fails to revive the AI trade
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

A record debut, a flat market

Anthropic's stock market debut on Thursday was supposed to be a shot in the arm for the AI trade. Instead, it was a bit of a dud, CNBC reported.

The AI startup priced its offering at $83 a share, raising $81 billion in the largest IPO of the year. The stock opened at $111.50, 34% above the offer price, and briefly pushed the company's valuation above $2 trillion before closing at $97.17, up 17% from the IPO price, Reuters reported. The offering was priced above the marketed range of $70 to $78 a share.

But the wider market did not follow. The S&P 500 fell 2%, the Nasdaq Composite dropped 2.3% and the Dow Jones Industrial Average lost 2.2%, Reuters reported, with the S&P 500 logging its sixth straight daily loss.

Why the reassurance did not land

The selloff was broad: Palantir and CoreWeave each fell 6%, while Oracle, Micron, Broadcom and Taiwan Semiconductor all lost at least 2%, CNBC reported. Nvidia fell 3.3%, Reuters reported.

"Anthropic's debut is a major test of the resilience of the AI infrastructure build-out," Morningstar analyst Mark McCaffrey wrote in a note published Thursday. He questioned whether Anthropic can become profitable enough to justify the spending behind its growth, noting the company is burning through large amounts of cash to fund AI training and infrastructure.

"The market is asking: if AI is so transformative, why isn't it making money faster?" said John Belton, a senior portfolio manager at Gabelli Funds. Amazon is Anthropic's biggest shareholder, holding a 24% stake, and Amazon, Alphabet, Microsoft and Nvidia all bought into the startup before the offering, CNBC reported.

Debut day, in numbersSource: CNBC, Reuters
  • IPO price$83
  • Opening price$111.50
  • Closing price$97.17
  • Gain on debutUp 17%
  • Amount raised$81 billion
  • Compute commitmentsAbout $900 billion
A stock exchange building facade at night under a dark sky
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

The math behind the doubt

Doubts center on the cost of the AI buildout. Anthropic's total compute commitments stand at about $900 billion, perhaps closer to $1 trillion, with about half due by 2030, Reuters reported. Analysis by the Financial Times suggests Anthropic will need to generate about $600 billion in annual revenue, far above the roughly $80 billion annualized revenue run rate it reported last month.

AI stocks had already started the week lower after a Reuters report said the Pentagon was seeking to cancel $3.7 billion in contracts awarded to the two AI companies, CNBC reported. CNBC also reported that OpenAI's growth was slowing and that the rival is reportedly planning to raise $100 billion next year.

Anthropic's debut was also a test for the IPO market, which has been in a slump for years. The listing showed investors are still willing to bet on AI, even as the market reassesses whether the buildout will generate enough return to justify the spending. This article is general market commentary, not investment advice.

Sources

Educational content, not investment advice. Facts as of the publish time above; figures come from the linked sources and markets change quickly. Genexus Alpha is not a registered investment adviser or broker.