FOMO's mirror image: panic selling and the disposition effect

FOMO pushes investors to buy at the top. The same fear pushes them to sell at the bottom. The disposition effect explains why winners get sold early and losers get held — and what the 2020 crash showed about panic.

AI illustration for this news story: FOMO's mirror image: panic selling and the disposition effect
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

FOMO has a twin, and it points the other way

The last article in this series looked at FOMO — the fear of missing out — pushing investors to buy what the crowd is hyping. That fear has a twin, and it points the other way. When prices fall fast, the same dread takes over in reverse: the fear of losing everything, of being the last one holding on while everyone else gets out. The crowd that rushed in at the top rushes out at the bottom, and the investor watching the red screen feels the same urgency to act now, before it is too late.

Both moves feel like the only safe choice in the moment, and both are driven by watching other people instead of by the investor's own plan. The root is loss aversion, the finding from prospect theory by Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky that losses loom larger than equivalent gains: the pain of a loss outweighs the pleasure of the same-sized gain. In a rally that pain is the pain of missing out. In a fall it is the pain of the loss itself, growing with every red day, until selling feels like the only way to stop it.

The two fears feed each other. The investor who buys at the top because the crowd is buying is the same investor who sells at the bottom because the crowd is selling. What matters is that the decision is being made by the crowd's mood, not by any judgement about what the holding is worth.

The disposition effect: sell the winner, keep the loser

Behavioural finance has a name for the habit: the disposition effect. It was named by Hersh Shefrin and Meir Statman in 1985: investors tend to sell winning investments too early and hold losing investments too long. The classic test came from Terrance Odean in 1998, who studied the trading records of 10,000 accounts at a large US discount broker between 1987 and 1993.

On days when investors sold something, they realised 14.8% of the gains available to them, but only 9.8% of the losses — winners were sold about 1.5 times as readily as losers. The reason is the reference point. Selling a winner feels like a win: the gain is banked, the decision is proven right. Selling a loser feels like admitting a mistake, so the investor holds on and waits to get back to even — to the purchase price — even when nothing about the business justifies waiting.

The habit backfires. The winners those investors sold went on to outperform the losers they kept by 3.4 percentage points on average over the following year. Take two holdings, one up 20% and one down 20%. Instinct says sell the winner and keep the loser. Repeated across a portfolio, that instinct trims the best ideas and nurses the worst ones — and the purchase price, the number the whole judgement hangs on, says nothing about what the holding is worth today.

March 2020: panic selling in 33 days

The fastest panic sale in modern market history came in early 2020. The S&P 500 closed at a record 3,386.15 on February 19, 2020. By March 23 it closed at 2,237.40 — down 33.9% in 33 calendar days, or 23 trading days. It crossed the 20% bear-market line in just 16 trading days, the fastest on record, and market-wide circuit breakers halted trading 4 times, on March 9, 12, 16 and 18.

In those weeks, selling felt like the only rational act. Headlines were unrelenting, the numbers on the screen were red every day, and every investor who sold seemed to be the sensible one. Then the market turned. The S&P 500 closed at a new record, 3,389.78, on August 18, 2020 — about 5 months after the low. Investors who sold near the bottom turned a paper loss into a real one and missed the recovery entirely.

That is not a promise that every crash recovers in 5 months — it does not. The fall of 2008 took years to heal. The lesson is narrower: a sale made in panic, at the moment fear peaks, is a decision made by the crowd's mood. It locks in the worst price of the episode and hands the recovery to whoever stayed.

FOMO's mirror image, in numbersSource: Investopedia, Nasdaq
  • Gains realised vs losses realised (Odean, 1998)14.8% vs 9.8%
  • How much more readily winners were soldAbout 1.5 times
  • Winners sold vs losers kept, next yearWinners ahead by 3.4 percentage points
  • S&P 500, February 19 to March 23, 20203,386.15 to 2,237.40, down 33.9%
  • S&P 500 new record3,389.78 on August 18, 2020
A dark empty trading floor with rows of glowing red and blue lights
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

Three checks before selling in a panic

First, the stranger test. Ask whether you would buy this holding today, at today's price, if you did not already own it. If the answer is no, the only reason you are holding is the price you paid — and the price you paid is history, not analysis. Judge the holding on what it is worth now, not on what it cost then.

Second, decide the exit before the fear arrives. Write down in advance what would make you sell — a broken thesis, a changed business — not a red day. That is the same discipline as position sizing: decide the loss first, on a calm day, so a panicked day cannot decide it for you. A rule written in advance is much harder for a crowd to overturn in the moment.

Third, shrink the noise. Check the portfolio on a schedule, not on every red day, and spend less time on the feeds where the crowd's fear spreads. The crowd's panic is as contagious as its greed, and it travels through the same screens. Discipline is boring by design — a plan, a rule, and a quiet inbox. That is the point. Educational content, not investment advice.

Sources

Educational content, not investment advice. Facts as of the publish time above; figures come from the linked sources and markets change quickly. Genexus Alpha is not a registered investment adviser or broker.