Rare-earth stocks sink as USA Rare Earth slides 12% on William Blair downgrade

USA Rare Earth fell more than 12% on Monday to its lowest close since April 2025, after William Blair cut the stock to neutral and pushed its estimates into 2028. MP Materials' revenue jumped 176% in the third quarter.

AI illustration for this news story: Rare-earth stocks sink as USA Rare Earth slides 12% on William Blair downgrade
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

A downgrade hits the sector's highflier

USA Rare Earth dropped more than 12% on Monday, its largest one-day percentage loss since June 5, when it fell 17%, and its lowest close since April 3, 2025, when it closed at $6.50. The stock has lost about 40% so far this year.

At the center of the selloff was a downgrade from analysts at William Blair, who cut the shares to the equivalent of neutral. The analysts said USA Rare Earth is facing raw-material shortages, and they pushed their sales and margin estimates for the company well into 2028.

Shares of Critical Metals, MP Materials and Rare Earths Americas also fell on Monday.

Feedstock shortages and a slow ramp

USA Rare Earth is "putting the pieces together for notable future upside," the William Blair analysts wrote. But recent feedstock shortages are adding to a list of near-term challenges, they said. Rare-earth feedstocks are any raw material, including mineral ores and waste, containing rare-earth elements that can be further processed.

"We have pushed out our sales and margin estimates well into 2028 given the continued impact that feedstock shortages" are having, the analysts wrote. Margins track the share of revenue a company keeps after paying its expenses, and there are also the usual operational challenges of ramping up production.

On the plus side, USA Rare Earth finished the September quarter with more than $1 billion in cash, ensuring "ample liquidity" through next year and perhaps longer if the feedstock problems persist, the analysts said.

Monday's rare-earth slideSource: MarketWatch
  • USA Rare Earth dropMore than 12%
  • Lowest close sinceApril 3, 2025
  • Largest one-day loss sinceJune 5, down 17%
  • Stock down this yearAbout 40%
  • Cash at end of SeptemberMore than $1 billion

MP Materials' mixed quarter

MP Materials, the largest United States rare-earth producer, reported third-quarter revenue of $147.7 million, up 176% from $53.6 million a year earlier, driven by higher sales of neodymium-praseodymium oxide and metal and stronger market pricing. The company also recorded $8.1 million of income under its price protection agreement with the United States government, taking consolidated revenue and price protection income to $155.8 million.

The net loss narrowed to $20.7 million from $41.8 million a year earlier, and adjusted earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization swung to $41.1 million from a loss of $12.6 million. Neodymium-praseodymium production rose 41% to 1,018 metric tons, and sales rose 94% to 1,020 metric tons.

The company said it completed magnet qualification with General Motors during the quarter, with saleable magnet deliveries and revenue starting in the fourth quarter. The Materials segment generated $133.5 million of revenue, up 322% from a year earlier, while the Magnetics segment generated $18.6 million.

An open-pit rare-earth mine at dusk, terraced rock walls and heavy machinery under a dark sky
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

Why Washington cares

The Trump administration earlier this year announced an investment and partnership with USA Rare Earth, as the United States government views the industry as vital to national security. Rare-earth minerals play an outsize role in energy, transportation and artificial intelligence, even though they are present in relative abundance in the Earth's crust.

They are labeled rare more because of the difficulties in extracting them, as they are rarely present in their pure forms. For the miners, the question now is whether the government backing and the demand from magnets and motors can outlast the feedstock shortages and the cash burn of building new plants. This article is general market commentary, not investment advice.

Sources

Educational content, not investment advice. Facts as of the publish time above; figures come from the linked sources and markets change quickly. Genexus Alpha is not a registered investment adviser or broker.