Analysts split on Anthropic IPO: excitement now, volatility ahead

Anthropic closed 17% above its $83 IPO price in a record $81.34 billion debut, but analysts are split: some see a future blue-chip stock, while Morningstar warns the shares remain highly volatile.

AI illustration for this news story: Analysts split on Anthropic IPO: excitement now, volatility ahead
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

A record debut, a wild first day

After pricing shares at $83 on Wednesday, above its initial range of $70 to $78, Anthropic stock opened at $111.50 just before noon EST. Shares slid in afternoon trading and closed at $97.17, roughly 17% above the IPO price, Morningstar reported.

On Wednesday, Anthropic raised $81.34 billion in its upsized IPO, the largest in history. The company raised the number and price of shares offered after underwriters received orders for more than six times the 825 million it planned to sell, and ultimately sold 980 million shares at $83 each, 12% above the midpoint of its target range, Morningstar reported.

The listing overtakes SpaceX's June $75 billion offering as the world's largest IPO. With its first-day pop, investors put the five-year-old company's diluted market capitalization at more than $1.6 trillion, on par with Broadcom. The company is raising another $26 billion through a private placement with corporate investors including Alphabet, Nvidia and Broadcom, and its underwriters still have the option to purchase an additional 147 million shares. If they do, Anthropic could raise as much as $119.5 billion before expenses, Morningstar reported.

The bull case: a future blue chip

Rebecca Walser, chief investment officer at Walser Wealth Management, said Anthropic's IPO is "exactly what the markets need to revive overall sentiment," adding that markets have been "depressed with all of the negativity in the AI complex over the past several weeks." She also said investors should avoid "chasing the IPO" and called the listing "the show me moment for the AI story," CNBC reported. Walser also noted that Anthropic was the first non-Chinese large language model developer to go public.

Ross Gerber, president and CEO of Gerber Kawasaki Wealth and Investment Management, said that for investors, the stock is "going to become a blue-chip stock like Google." Charlie McElligott, a strategist at Nomura, said investors were "foaming at the mouth" for the offering, with allocations "impossibly low," CNBC reported.

The successful IPO has enabled Anthropic to raise north of $100 billion in capital, Morningstar noted, and the capital raise, coupled with the $132 billion of cash on the balance sheet, should help the firm meet its roughly $900 billion of compute commitments even if revenue growth stalls. OpenAI, Anthropic's top rival, is expected to IPO in 2027, Morningstar reported.

The debut, in numbersSource: CNBC, Morningstar
  • IPO price$83
  • Opening price$111.50
  • Closing price$97.17
  • First-day gain17%
  • Raised$81.34 billion
  • Morningstar fair value$92
A stock exchange building facade at dawn
AI-generated illustration, not a photo.

The caution: volatility and a $92 fair value

Morningstar maintained its $92 fair value estimate for Anthropic, with a 3-star rating, a narrow economic moat and a very high uncertainty rating. "The shares remain highly volatile," said Malik Ahmed Khan, senior equity analyst at Morningstar, who advised investors to "carefully" assess the company as a long-term business.

Khan said Anthropic's success will depend on three fronts: whether the firm can scale enterprise adoption of its models, whether its models continue to improve and unlock economically useful capabilities, and whether Anthropic can capture some of the value the AI ecosystem creates, Morningstar reported.

The listing is also seen as a test of the recently beleaguered AI trade. The Morningstar US Artificial Intelligence Index has fallen nearly 20% since early October. On Thursday, shares of Advanced Micro Devices slumped nearly 8%, while Nvidia declined 3% and Broadcom fell 2%. Amazon, Alphabet and Meta Platforms all dropped more than 3%, and the Morningstar US Total Market Index fell about 2%. This article is general market commentary, not investment advice.

Sources

Educational content, not investment advice. Facts as of the publish time above; figures come from the linked sources and markets change quickly. Genexus Alpha is not a registered investment adviser or broker.